Peer Review Notes
A working document for capturing review feedback, critiques, and revision tasks for Resonance Substrate Model papers.
1. Summary of the Work#
Brief overview of the manuscript being reviewed.
2. Major Comments#
- High‑level issues
- Conceptual gaps
- Methodological concerns
- Missing references or context
3. Minor Comments#
- Clarity improvements
- Typos or formatting issues
- Small technical corrections
4. Questions for the Authors#
- Points requiring clarification
- Ambiguities in methods or results
5. Recommendations#
- Accept / Minor revision / Major revision / Reject
- Justification for recommendation
6. Action Items#
A checklist for revisions based on the review.
Quicklinks#
- manuscript cover letter
- manuscript PDF Manuscript Header
- overview resonance substrate model
- papers peer review notes
- papers README
- papers replication report template
- papers substrate model whitepaper citation_map
- papers substrate model whitepaper manuscript
- papers substrate model whitepaper README
- papers substrate model whitepaper figures README
- papers substrate model whitepaper supplementary README
- previous folder